To dismiss an experience as not attainable simply because one has not experienced it seems to be standard operating procedure for mainstream news.
With two natural, home births on the books, I cannot say either experience was orgasmic. However feelings of ecstasy (an overpowering emotion or exaltation; a state of sudden, intense feeling) were surely present at both births.
I don’t find the movie trailer for Orgasmic Birth to be harmful to the natural childbirth movement, and certainly not an invitation to bash the most innovative and respected midwife that I am aware of: Ina May Gaskin. Yet film critic Avril Moore has done just that in this mean spirited article; Orgasmic birth and other old midwives’ tales.
Mainstream media is constantly bombarding us with stories of painful, dreadful, miserable, and excruciating childbirth. So what are we to expect with these images ingrained in our psyche? How refreshing to see women discuss birth and not appear horrified, fearful and disturbed by natural birth.
If we stand any chance at changing our culture’s highly technical, manipulated, unnatural, and hospital managed, birth model; we need to begin to incorporate new ideas about birth into our consciousness. Our goal should be directed at ridding ourselves of the damaging beliefs surrounding childbirth that send 99% of women to the hospital, 33% of which will undergo surgery in the form of a cesarean section to bring their baby into the world.
Why has the author chosen to diminish the work and credentials of Ina May Gaskin? This world renowned midwife has helped “directly” over 2000 women bring their babies into the world with natural home births, not to mention the untold tens or perhaps hundreds of thousands of women she has helped indirectly through her books, lectures, and trainings. To depict her as some flaky, flower child hippie is just sad.
I highly doubt Avril has read the book, Spiritual Midwifery.
She describes it awkwardly:
This hippie heyday instructional manual became the home-birth movement’s bible, while stories of the commune where Gaskin lived were the stuff of dreams for anyone “seriously into” natural birth.
The book encompasses so much more than the “stuff of dreams”, many different kinds of birth are represented in the book; including miscarriage, breech, hospital birth, cesarean, painful experiences, and infant death.
Spiritual Midwifery fills a much needed niche for women seeking information vetted by real life experience. These experiences are outside the conventional and prevalent, What to Expect when Expecting style book, (which is near useless to a woman looking for first hand birth stories). So Gaskin’s book has remained thirty years later, a huge value to not only to expecting Moms planning a home birth, but to any one interested in gaining meaningful insight into the multi-faceted changes that occur during any birth in any setting.
Belief’s are powerful don’t let a film critic choose your beliefs for you!
Avril:
“let’s get real, and stop equating this choice with some hokey idea of “ecstasy” when we all know natural birth is pretty much like trying to push a football through the eye of a needle “
Her sad choice to hold this belief aligns perfectly with a 99% cesarean culture that seems to loom before our not too distant future.
Wouldn’t it be much more useful to hold the belief that birth can be ecstasy, and free of misery?
Avril equates such a belief with “hippie claptrap”
Having a “natural” labour at home with the help of a midwife does not necessarily mean you eat lentils (or placentas), wear alpaca ponchos or remain serenely submissive when in pain.
This stereotype promoted by Gaskin on the Orgasmic Birth website is exactly what drives women into the arms of their scalpel-wielding obstetricians, not to mention encouraging a good dose of post-natal depression due to profound disappointment with their labour.
Well, I have not seen the movie but neither has Avril.
How disappointing to discover last week a flyer promoting the private screening of a new short film, Orgasmic Birth — the Best Kept Secret, by none other than this weary, world-renowned midwife.
Curious to see what her contemporary take on modern birthing practices would reveal, I logged on to www.orgasmicbirth.com, only to discover a much greyer Gaskin still expounding — “it is possible to have an ecstatic birth — in fact, it is the best natural high that I know of”.
I can say, unequivocally, that my birth experiences have been the biggest highs of my life. In Liams Birth story I describe the feeling of wanting to do it again” and thats just how I felt.
I choose to believe …that birthing is, for myself and my baby, pain free,
…that I can experience a healthy and safe birth in my own home.
…that the path of least resistance is found within my consciousness and mine alone,
… that cesarean births are wonderful blessings if and when they are needed,
… that I am very fortunate to be able to birth at home with very good results.
If you are truly believing and expecting a pain free birth, it is far more likely your experience will be in relative alignment with that expectation. Why? Because if you belive it you will plan, prepare, and act in a manner that will bring you the result.
If on the other hand, you go Avril’s way all “footballs and needle eyes”, well then your actions will be in alignment with your beliefs and a self-fulfilling prophesy may be unavoidable.
In my big fat pregnant opinion IMBFPO the film critic “has issues”. : )
Here is wishing all women a more pleasurable birthing experience.
Abbie

